Thanksgiving lands on Thursday, November 26 this year, which gives you nine days to settle the only question that actually matters at the table: what is in the glass. The good news is that the answer has gotten simpler. Every sommelier, wine writer and pairing guide I read this week converges on the same advice — stop chasing the turkey and start pairing the trimmings.
Pair the trimmings, not the bird
Roast turkey is a blank slate. What sits next to it is not: cranberry sauce with a sweet-sour snap, gravy with real body, sweet potatoes under a marshmallow lid, sausage stuffing, brussels sprouts charred in a hot pan, and somebody’s aunt bringing a dish with ginger in it. No single bottle handles all of that. What you want instead are wines with bright acidity and modest alcohol, so each glass refreshes the palate instead of weighing it down.
That combination — acid plus restraint — is the whole strategy. It is also why the same four bottles show up in nearly every serious guide published this month.
The four-bottle lineup
- Off-dry Riesling, poured first. A German Kabinett from the Mosel or a Finger Lakes Riesling with a few grams of residual sugar. That touch of sweetness meets the sweet potatoes and the cranberry, while the acid cuts straight through the gravy. Serve this one before anything else: it wakes up the palate rather than coating it.
- Cru Beaujolais, second. Fleurie or Morgon, gamay, around 12.5% alcohol, served slightly cool. It is the most food-flexible red on the table and the least likely to put anyone to sleep before pie. Note the calendar: Beaujolais Nouveau is released on the third Thursday, which is November 19, so the party bottle arrives just in time. If you want the full Nouveau rundown, last week’s guide has it.
- A warm-climate red for the dark meat. Zinfandel, or a Rhône-style GSM if you prefer something with more pepper than jam. One bottle is enough — this is the pour for the people who insist red is the only real wine.
- Something sparkling at the door. Crémant de Bourgogne, a dry Finger Lakes sparkling, or a grower Champagne if the year calls for it. Fizz handles arrival, coats, and the twenty minutes when dinner is late.
Four bottles for six to eight people is about right. If your crowd runs larger, buy two Rieslings before you buy a second Zinfandel — the Riesling is the bottle that empties first and the one nobody thinks to bring.
Buying in the city without losing an afternoon
Flatiron Wines & Spirits at 873 Broadway runs free in-store tastings most Thursdays and Fridays from about 5 to 7 p.m. and most Saturdays from about noon to 3 p.m. No ticket, no RSVP — you walk in, you taste, you leave with something you did not plan on. Their wine classes are a different story: those sell out fast, so check the events calendar before the holiday week swallows your evenings.
The other rule that saves Thanksgivings: shop by Tuesday, November 24. By Wednesday afternoon the good shelves are picked over and every clerk in the city is explaining Riesling to someone in a hurry.
Three new rooms worth a Tuesday
If your holiday plans include guests you would rather take out than cook for, the fall openings are unusually strong.
Bar Chimera, 550 Madison Avenue
Part of Gracious Hospitality’s Midtown expansion, Bar Chimera puts three drinking ideas in one luxurious room: Martinis, whiskey, and wine. The wine side leans on an extensive aged Madeira program and hard-to-find pours, which makes it the rare Midtown address where a glass can cost more than the entrée and be worth it. Splurge territory, not Tuesday territory — unless the Tuesday in question is a celebration.
Graciela, 81 Greenwich Avenue
An Argentine tavern and steakhouse from Pablo Rivero, the restaurateur behind Buenos Aires’ Don Julio. Live-fire cooking and big cuts get the attention, but the list is the reason to book: beverage director Jirka Jireh Rivera goes well past the obligatory Malbec into high-elevation Sémillon and old-vine Bastardo. Ask what is open by the glass and let the team steer.
Crybaby, 153 Bowery
Alpine wine on the Lower East Side — Jura and Savoie, Chartreuse in the cocktails, hearty food to match. Open Wednesday through Sunday, 5 p.m. to 2 a.m., which makes it the correct answer after a late show or a long week. It is the kind of room where the second bottle arrives before you have finished discussing the first.
And for the tiny-room experience, Bar à Part at 72 Bedford Street in the West Village seats about fifteen people across six two-tops, takes walk-ins only, and pours a list built on southern France and northern Spain. Arrive at opening or plan to come back.
Three dates for the calendar
- November 21–22 — Uncork the Holidays, Shawangunk Wine Trail. Three itineraries of four wineries each, with tasting flights and seasonal food, roughly ninety minutes north of the city. It repeats December 5–6 and December 12 if this weekend does not work. Details at the trail’s events page.
- December 9–12 — La Tablée, the Rhône Valley festival, back in New York for its sixth edition and the sister event to La Paulée and La Fête du Champagne. Northern and southern Rhône under one roof, from small growers to the big houses. Tickets are on sale now at latalenyc.com.
- Any Thursday — the free tasting at Flatiron. No cost, no commitment, and a far better use of an hour than scrolling a wine list online.
The night before
Wednesday the 25th is amateur night in every wine shop in Manhattan. Skip it. Open one of the bottles you already bought, cook something simple, and go to bed early — Thursday is a long service. If you do need a last-minute bottle, the move is a wine bar with a retail shelf rather than a crowded store at 6 p.m.
Pour something with acid, keep the alcohol low, put the good glasses out, and let the trimmings do the arguing. Happy Thanksgiving, New York.
